# Halloween This or That Questions for Kids and Adults Source: https://thisorthatquestion.com/halloween-this-or-that Updated: 2026-11-11 Candy, costume, monster and movie pairs for class or a costume party, plus a round for adults. ## Quick facts - Halloween falls on October 31 every year, so most classrooms and offices play this or that Halloween rounds in the last week of October. - The first jack-o'-lanterns in Ireland and Scotland were carved from turnips. Pumpkins became the standard in North America. - Candy pairs split a group most evenly when both sides are the same type, such as two chocolate bars or two sour candies. - A Halloween this or that round of 15 pairs takes about 10 minutes with a class of 20 kids. - Keep gore and horror movie pairs for adults. Kids under 8 do best with candy, costume and friendly monster pairs. ## Halloween candy this or that Candy is the strongest topic in any this or that Halloween edition. Everyone has a favorite bar and a candy they trade away. 1. Reese's Cups or Butterfinger? 2. Twix or Kit Kat? 3. Candy corn or Gummy worms? 4. Skittles or M&M's? 5. One full-size bar or Five fun-size bars? 6. Chocolate bars or Lollipops? 7. Caramel apple or Kettle corn? 8. Tootsie Rolls or Smarties? 9. Trade your candy or Keep it all? 10. Eat it all tonight or Make it last a month? 11. Almond Joy or Mounds? 12. Nerds or Starburst? ## Costumes and trick-or-treating 1. Scary costume or Funny costume? 2. Homemade costume or Store-bought costume? 3. Group costume or Solo costume? 4. Trick-or-treating or Trunk-or-treat? 5. Haunted house or Hayride? 6. Glow sticks or Flashlight? 7. Witch or Wizard? 8. Mask or Face paint? 9. Corn maze or Pumpkin patch? 10. Pillowcase or Plastic pumpkin bucket? 11. Hand out candy or Go trick-or-treating? ## Monsters and spooky things These Halloween themed this or that questions work for every age. Ask kids to make the monster's sound for their pick. 1. Black cat or Owl? 2. Skeleton or Zombie? 3. Frankenstein or Dracula? 4. Spiders or Snakes? 5. Ghost or Vampire? 6. Werewolf or Mummy? 7. Friendly ghost or Spooky ghost? 8. Jack-o'-lantern or Scarecrow? 9. Cauldron or Crystal ball? 10. Graveyard or Haunted mansion? ## Halloween movies, music and activities 1. Hocus Pocus or Halloweentown? 2. The Nightmare Before Christmas or Coraline? 3. Scary movie or Halloween cartoon? 4. Ghost stories or Spooky games? 5. Throw a party or Go to a party? 6. Bobbing for apples or Mummy wrap race? 7. Roasted pumpkin seeds or Popcorn balls? 8. Pumpkin spice or Apple cinnamon? 9. Monster Mash or Thriller? 10. The Addams Family or The Munsters? ## Halloween this or that questions for adults Use this round at an office party or a costume party. The pairs stay work-safe but lean on adult habits and horror tastes. 1. Costume party or Horror movie marathon? 2. Escape room or Haunted attraction? 3. Spiked cider or Pumpkin spice latte? 4. Answer the door or Hide with the lights off? 5. Classic slasher or Psychological horror? 6. Night in a haunted hotel or Night in a cemetery? 7. Ghost tour or Corn maze at night? 8. Decorate in September or Decorate on October 30? 9. Couples costume or Pop culture costume? 10. Buy candy early or Buy candy on sale November 1? ## How to play Halloween this or that 1. Pick 15 pairs: 5 candy, 5 costume or monster, and 5 from the movies or adults section. 2. Tape a pumpkin sign on one wall and a ghost sign on the other. Pumpkin means the first option, ghost means the second. 3. Read each pair aloud as "Skeleton or Zombie?" and have players walk to the wall for their pick. 4. Ask one player from each side to give a reason in one sentence. 5. Finish with the candy round and hand a piece of the winning candy to that side. ## Tips for Halloween this or that questions - Check for allergies before using real candy as a prize. Stickers or pencils work as a swap. - Skip gory pairs with kids under 10. Swap "Psychological horror" for "Friendly ghost" style options. - Let players answer in costume voice. A vampire who explains a pick in a Dracula accent gets the whole room laughing. - Play it the week before October 31. Kids are already planning costumes and talk more. - For an online meeting, post each pair as a poll in Zoom, Teams or Slido and share the results on screen. ## Frequently asked questions ### What is Halloween this or that? Halloween this or that is a two-option question game with a spooky theme, such as "Werewolf or Mummy?" or "Twix or Kit Kat?". Each player picks one side and explains. Teachers use it in October morning meetings, and hosts use it at costume parties. ### What are good Halloween this or that questions? Good Halloween this or that questions pair two spooky options with no wrong answer, such as Skeleton or Zombie, Hocus Pocus or Halloweentown, and Glow sticks or Flashlight. Mix candy, costume and monster pairs so every player finds a topic they care about. ### What are some halloween candy this or that pairs? Popular Halloween candy pairs include Twix or Kit Kat, Reese's Cups or Butterfinger, Candy corn or Gummy worms, and Skittles or M&M's. Pairs of the same candy type split the group best. Add "One full-size bar or Five fun-size bars" for a fun argument about value. ### What are halloween this or that questions for adults? Halloween this or that questions for adults cover horror tastes and party habits. Try Classic slasher or Psychological horror, Escape room or Haunted attraction, and Answer the door or Hide with the lights off. They stay clean enough for an office party. ### How do I run this or that Halloween questions in class? Run them as a walk-to-the-wall game. Post a pumpkin sign on one wall and a ghost sign on the other, read each pair, and have students walk to their pick. Fifteen pairs fill about 10 minutes with 20 students. ### Are Halloween this or that questions OK for young kids? Yes, if you pick the pairs. Candy, costume and friendly monster pairs suit kids from age 4. Leave out horror movies, graveyards and anything gory. Kids under 6 answer best when you hold up a picture or toy for each option. ### Can I use these for a Halloween this or that post on social media? Yes. Pick one pair per post and use the Instagram Stories poll sticker so followers can vote. Candy pairs such as Twix or Kit Kat get the most votes because everyone has a quick opinion. Share the results the next day.